top of page

Value-Driven
Digital Identity Future

Value Sensitive Design Approach

Master Thesis Strategic Product Design / Melissa Kramer

Graduation Company: INNOPAY Management Consultancy, Amsterdam

#value tension   #digital identity  #ecosystem #transisiton design #value sensitive design

How might we create a digital identity future that embeds the values of various users and stakeholders, while using technology responsibly?

The Situation

The EU Commission is revisiting the current regulation eIDAS 2.0 on

identification and trust services and building an Architecture Reference

Framework (ARF) for future Digital Identity Wallets. This creates the outline for the emergent ecosystem for future transactions in Europe.

The Consequences

Many sectors that rely on the identification of users have to accept Digital Identity Wallets as verification means for their users. The development process makes the Digital Identity Wallets the future facilitators of the emergent ecosystem in which stakeholders have different preferences for the solution. Many value tensions arise. 

Social

Economical

Bildschirmfoto 2023-07-06 um 14.49.30.png

Design Process 

1 Focus Groups User + Experts | Current feelings and experiences with digital identity in reflection with digital ethics

IMG_6128 2.JPG
Bildschirmfoto 2023-07-08 um 13.45.08.png

Tool: Envisioning Cards, Prototype

Process: Gamified Research with cards that foster conversations

IMG_6136 2.JPG

Final Reflection

2 Stakeholder Research | Value Stream from System to Product
Digital Identity Experience + Balancing Technology Ethics

A4 - 31.jpg

Tool 1: Sensitizer for Users, Verifying Parties & Experts

IMG_6829.JPG

Tool 2: Value Cards for Experience and Ethical Reflection

Tool 3: Draw it out

Bildschirmfoto 2023-07-30 um 14.36.14.png
IMG_6760.JPG

Tool 2: Ecosystem Map

Design Intervention | Transition Design

Based on transition design, the final design aims to create a framework that can be used over time to balance values and provide an ethical technology foundation. 

Strategic dialogues help stakeholders to form a shared understanding of their value differences and value tensions, and take responsible technology action.

Welcome to the Common Ground

Bildschirmfoto 2023-07-06 um 14.58.17.png

Storytelling

Thesis Synthesis Map

Print A3's_Zeichenfläche 1-05 1.png

Reflection

I see many experts talking about unethical practices and that we should create a better way of dealing with personal data and work on data privacy. However, the complexity of digital identity from a technical perspective makes it hard to generate a common understanding of where confidentiality and security is created. 

To find a common language, I saw the common ground as a necessary outcome of my research, as talking about change starts with a reflective process. Having a framework and process in place in which conversations take place and all different perspectives are taken into account helps to talk about the important factors from the start without talking only buzzwords 'like privacy' without putting it in the verification context and the stakeholders involved in that process and the mechanisms used. 

Therefore the Common Ground can be a framework for a diversity of verification experiences or value tensions between stakeholders in general. 

The Common Ground is also a brand. 
It showcases that value tensions need to be solved from the start. This way, nobody needs to lose their energy on making that point because everyone is there to understand what is happening. 


> Iterations and tests need to happen to see if it is working sufficiently

bottom of page